The plan sponsor (the employer that sponsors a 401(k) or 403(b) plan) and its plan fiduciaries are responsible for choosing the plan’s investment options and monitoring them over time. Few HR and finance teams have the time or training to do that alone, so most plans hire professional help. That help usually comes in one of two forms, named after the sections of ERISA that define them: a 3(21) Investment Advisor or a 3(38) Fiduciary.
The difference matters. It decides who makes the investment decisions, who is responsible if those decisions are imprudent, and how much work stays with the plan fiduciaries. This article explains both roles, what potential liability the plan sponsor retains even after hiring a 3(38) Fiduciary, how to choose one, and what it typically costs.
What is a 3(38) Fiduciary?
A 3(38) Fiduciary is an investment manager that the plan formally appoints to select, monitor and replace the plan’s investment options. Through this appointment the plan’s fiduciaries delegate to the 3(38) Fiduciary the full discretion to make changes to the investment lineup offered to the plan’s participants.
The key distinction is discretion. A 3(38) Fiduciary doesn’t recommend changes for the plan fiduciaries to approve; it makes them. It typically develops and follows the plan’s investment policy statement. It also decides when a fund should be replaced, chooses the replacement, and gives the recordkeeper instructions for moving participants’ money.
Because the 3(38) Fiduciary makes those decisions, ERISA generally relieves the plan sponsor and other plan fiduciaries of liability for the investment choices made by the 3(38) Fiduciary.
What is a 3(21) Investment Advisor?
In contrast, a 3(21) Investment Advisor gives the plan fiduciaries investment advice for a fee and accepts fiduciary responsibility for that advice. But the plan fiduciaries still make the final decisions. If the 3(21) Investment Advisor recommends replacing a fund, the plan fiduciaries decide whether to do it, and they remain responsible for that decision. In practice, the 3(21) Investment Advisor and the plan fiduciaries share responsibility for the investment lineup.
A 3(21) arrangement suits plan sponsors that want professional input but prefer to keep control. It also means more work for the plan fiduciaries, and more of the risk stays with them.
3(38) vs. 3(21): the main differences
| 3(38) Fiduciary | 3(21) Investment Advisor | |
|---|---|---|
| Who makes investment decisions | The 3(38) Fiduciary | The plan fiduciaries, based on the 3(21) Investment Advisor’s recommendations |
| Who is responsible for those decisions | The 3(38) Fiduciary | Shared by the plan fiduciaries and the 3(21) Investment Advisor |
| What the plan fiduciaries do | Prudently select and monitor the 3(38) Fiduciary | Review recommendations, vote on changes, document their reasons |
| Who develops and follows the investment policy statement | Virtually always the 3(38) Fiduciary | Usually the plan fiduciaries, with the 3(21) Investment Advisor’s help |
| Best fit | Plan fiduciaries who want to reduce their liability related to selecting and monitoring investments | Plan sponsors and plan fiduciaries who want to keep control of the lineup |
What potential liability is retained by the plan sponsor after hiring a 3(38) Fiduciary
Hiring a 3(38) Fiduciary is itself a fiduciary decision, and it doesn’t fully eliminate the plan sponsor’s responsibilities. The plan sponsor still has to:
- Select the 3(38) Fiduciary prudently. Compare several qualified firms on services, process, and fees, and document why you chose the one you did.
- Monitor the 3(38) Fiduciary. Review its reports, check that it follows the investment policy statement, and confirm its fees remain reasonable.
- Stay out of the 3(38) Fiduciary’s decisions. If the plan fiduciaries steer fund choices, override the 3(38) Fiduciary, or insist on particular funds, they can take back the responsibility they delegated.
- Oversee everything else. Recordkeeping fees, plan administration and the other service providers are still the plan sponsor’s responsibility, unless they are delegated separately.
In other words, a 3(38) Fiduciary takes fiduciary responsibility for the plan’s investment decisions, but not other plan administration responsibilities.
Which investment service model is right for your plan?
There is no single right answer, but a few questions usually settle it:
- Do the plan fiduciaries have the time and expertise to make investment decisions and document them well? If not, a 3(38) Fiduciary is often the better fit.
- Do the plan fiduciaries want to keep control of specific choices, such as the default investment or a fund that employees value? A 3(21) Investment Advisor leaves that control with them, along with the responsibility.
- How quickly can the plan fiduciaries act? A change recommended by a 3(21) Investment Advisor waits for a meeting and a vote. A 3(38) Fiduciary can act as soon as its process calls for it.
- Is any price differential warranted? There is usually not a significant difference in the fee rates of the two models. Some firms offer the 3(38) at a discount or at the same price as a 3(21), whereas other firms charge more for the 3(38).
Some plan sponsors ask providers to bid both ways, as a 3(21) Investment Advisor and as a 3(38) Fiduciary, so the plan fiduciaries can compare the services and fees side by side before deciding.
How to choose a 3(38) Fiduciary
Run a competitive search, much as you would for a recordkeeper (see how to run a 401(k) recordkeeper RFP). Most qualified firms will meet the basics:
- Written acceptance of full 3(38) fiduciary responsibility
- Developing and following the investment policy statement
- Regular investment monitoring and reports to the plan fiduciaries
- Fiduciary liability insurance
- A clear process for making fund changes, including who initiates them, how participants’ money is mapped to new funds, and how notices are given
The real differences are usually in the details:
- Share classes. Does the 3(38) Fiduciary consistently choose the lowest-cost share class of each fund available to the plan, taking revenue sharing and fee leveling into account?
- Selection criteria. What criteria does it use to determine whether an investment option passes its screens?
- Difficulty of the screening process. Does it require funds to rank in the top half, third or quartile of their peers, and how long can a fund fail its screens before it must be removed?
- Independence from the plan fiduciaries. Does its process keep the plan fiduciaries out of fund selection, so the protection the plan is paying for holds up?
- Conflicts of interest. Does the firm, or a company it’s affiliated with, earn anything from the funds it selects?
- Understanding of recordkeeping costs. Does it account for how the recordkeeper’s pricing and revenue sharing affect what participants actually pay?
- Fees. There can sometimes be material differences in the fees proposed by qualified firms offering similar services.
Read the service agreement closely
The service agreement defines what the 3(38) Fiduciary has actually agreed to do, and it’s where many providers attempt to limit their exposure. Before signing, confirm that the agreement:
- States plainly that the firm is acting as a 3(38) Fiduciary and acknowledges its fiduciary status in writing.
- Covers every investment option you expect it to manage, including the default investment (QDIA). Note any exclusions, such as a brokerage window or company stock.
- Doesn’t quietly shift risk back to the plan through broad limits on liability or indemnification clauses.
- Explains how fees are calculated, how they change as plan assets grow, and how either side can end the agreement.
What does a 3(38) Fiduciary cost?
Most 3(38) Fiduciaries charge an asset-based fee, i.e., a small percentage of plan assets each year, sometimes with a minimum annual fee for smaller plans. That fee is in addition to the funds’ own expenses and the recordkeeping fee.
For example, in 2023 we ran a 3(38) search for a plan sponsor with about 400 participants. Ten firms were invited to bid. Two declined, and all eight others agreed to take full 3(38) fiduciary responsibility. Only four of them consistently selected the lowest-cost share class of each fund, so the other four were eliminated. The two finalists bid about 0.05% of plan assets a year (5 basis points) or slightly less.
Two considerations matter in addition to the initial fee rate. First, an asset-based fee rises as the plan grows, even if the work doesn’t, so ask how the fee changes as assets increase. Second, a 3(38) Fiduciary that reliably picks the lowest-cost share classes can save participants far more than the typical difference between two competing 3(38) firms’ fees.
Common mistakes
- Assuming a 3(38) Fiduciary removes all fiduciary responsibility. The plan sponsor still selects and monitors the 3(38) Fiduciary and oversees the rest of the plan.
- Continuing to steer fund choices after appointing a 3(38) Fiduciary.
- Hiring a 3(38) Fiduciary without a competitive search, or simply adding 3(38) services from the plan’s current advisor without comparing alternatives.
- Not reading the service agreement for exclusions and limits on liability.
- Ignoring share classes and revenue sharing, which often cost participants more than the 3(38) Fiduciary’s own fee.
- Paying twice for the same work, for example, keeping a 3(21) Investment Advisor to monitor investments that a 3(38) Fiduciary is already responsible for.
How ClearSage helps
ClearSage Advisory Group is an independent retirement plan consulting firm. We are not an investment advisor and don’t act as a 3(21) Investment Advisor or 3(38) Fiduciary, so we have no stake in which firm a plan chooses. We help plan sponsors decide which model fits their plan, run competitive searches for 3(21) Investment Advisors and 3(38) Fiduciaries (often in parallel with a recordkeeper search), negotiate fees and service agreements, and monitor the 3(38) Fiduciary once it’s hired. We can also take fiduciary responsibility for selecting and monitoring all the plan’s other service providers, such as the recordkeeper.
We have also helped registered investment advisors design their own 3(21) and 3(38) service offerings and draft their service agreements, so we know where providers tend to limit their liability and shift risk to their clients.
Read what a retirement plan consultant does, see our services for employers, or contact us to talk about your plan.
