A request for proposal (RFP) is a formal, competitive bid. The employer describes its retirement plan and what it needs, invites a group of recordkeepers to propose services and pricing, and then uses that competition to select a provider and negotiate terms.
It is also the most reliable way to answer the question required of every plan fiduciary: are we paying reasonable fees for the services we receive? A published average tells you only the average of what other plans pay, including plans that are paying unreasonable fees. A competitive bid tells you what the market will charge your plan, today, for the services you actually need. Those two numbers are often far apart. (See why average isn’t reasonable.)
This guide walks through the six steps of a well-run recordkeeper RFP, using an anonymized search recently completed by ClearSage for a client, and closes with answers to the questions employers ask most.
When to run an RFP instead of benchmarking
A fee benchmark is a good annual check-up. An RFP is the right tool when:
- The plan’s fees have not been tested in the market for three years or more.
- The plan has grown substantially in participants or assets, which changes how providers price it.
- A benchmark suggests the plan is paying more than it should.
- Service problems keep coming back: payroll errors, slow responses, participant complaints.
- The company is going through a merger, a payroll change, or a change in plan design.
- The committee wants to compare service models, such as adding a 3(38) investment manager or a 3(16) administrative fiduciary.
An RFP doesn’t mean you have to switch providers. Many plans stay with their current recordkeeper or investment manager after an RFP, at a lower price and on better terms. The competition is what produces that result.
The six steps of a recordkeeper RFP
Step 1: Decide what the plan needs before you look at bids
Start by reviewing the plan document, service agreements, fee disclosures and recent service problems, and interviewing the people who deal with the plan every day. Then agree on the criteria that matter most and how much each one weighs, before any proposals arrive. Setting the criteria first keeps the decision objective and makes it far easier to document later.
Typical criteria include the reasonableness of fees, payroll integration, investment flexibility, how revenue sharing is handled, participant education and website quality, error prevention in the contribution process, the willingness to accept fiduciary responsibility for administrative tasks, and the provider’s client retention.
Step 2: Choose bidders and write the RFP
Invite enough firms to create real competition. For recordkeeping, that usually means eight to twelve providers of different types and sizes, plus your current recordkeeper. Fewer bidders mean less leverage.
The RFP itself should combine standard questions with questions specific to your plan. Most recordkeepers can answer the SPARK Institute’s standard data request, which makes responses easier to compare. Add questions that separate the providers on the points you care about, and ask for:
- Pricing in a format you choose, ideally a flat dollar amount per participant rather than a percentage of assets, so the fee doesn’t rise automatically as accounts grow.
- Every source of revenue the provider will earn from the plan and its participants, including revenue sharing, float, managed accounts, IRA rollovers and proprietary investments.
- Any requirement to use the provider’s own investment products, and any discount tied to them.
- A copy of the service agreement, and how long the proposed price is guaranteed.
Step 3: Screen the responses and pick finalists
Score each response against the criteria from Step 1. Ask follow-up questions in cases in which two proposals can’t be compared apples-to-apples. Then narrow the field to three or four finalists. This is the first point of leverage: providers who want to reach the finals often improve their pricing before presentations. Ask providers whose price or services stand out from the rest to improve their proposals if they want to reach the finalist stage.
Step 4: Hold finalist presentations
Give every finalist the same agenda so the committee can easily make meaningful comparisons. Useful topics include a live demonstration of the participant website, how the payroll and contribution process is designed to prevent errors (rather than fix them after they have occurred), participant education and guidance, and the provider’s own case for why it is different and better. Have each committee member score each presentation on the same scale.
Step 5: Negotiate, and keep the competition alive
Keep at least two or three providers in the running until the contract is signed. Each stage of the process (making the shortlist, becoming a finalist, winning the decision, signing the contract) is another chance to improve price and terms. Look past the headline recordkeeping fee to:
- Price guarantees and how long they last
- Who keeps the interest earned on cash in transit (float)
- Fees for one-off services such as loans and distributions, and any additional fees for out-of-the-ordinary projects
- How revenue sharing is credited back to participants (fee leveling)
- Contract terms that make it costly to leave
Step 6: Decide, document and implement
Choose the provider that offers the best combination of services and fees for participants, and write down why. When two providers’ services are not materially different but their prices are, the lower price should generally win. Make sure the signed contract matches the proposal, plan the transition, and keep the full record: the RFP, the responses, the scoring, the meeting notes and the rationale. That file is the evidence of a prudent process if the decision is ever questioned.
From sending the RFP to making a final decision, a typical recordkeeper search takes about three to four months.
A real example: one plan, two searches, 22 bidders
In 2023 an employer with about 400 participants and under $50 million in plan assets hired ClearSage to oversee its retirement plan. Its plan paid its recordkeeper an asset-based fee of 0.10%, or about $114 per participant per year. Because the employer also wanted an investment manager to take full responsibility for the fund lineup, we ran two searches side by side: one for a recordkeeper and one for a 3(38) investment manager.
The recordkeeper search. In mid-March, an RFP went to 12 recordkeepers. All 12 answered a short questionnaire, and 10 also provided a full SPARK-format response. Eleven offered fee leveling, ten could integrate fully with the employer’s payroll system, and six offered to take on some 3(16) administrative fiduciary responsibility. The top four were invited to present in late May; one was eliminated right after the presentations, and negotiations continued with the remaining three.
The investment manager search. An RFP with 29 questions went to 10 investment managers. Two declined to bid. All eight remaining firms would take full 3(38) responsibility, but only four consistently selected the lowest-cost share class of each fund, and the others were eliminated. The top two presented to the committee.
Putting them together. Two recordkeepers and two investment managers were each prudent choices on their own. We then compared all four combinations, because how a recordkeeper prices its services and how an investment manager selects funds affect each other. One combination clearly offered participants the best value.
The result. The incumbent recordkeeper kept the business, but not at the old price. Its first bid was $108 per participant, a flat dollar fee instead of a percentage of assets. Before finalist presentations it dropped to $99, about 13% below what the plan had been paying. The competition among the final three then produced further pricing and service concessions: the final fee was $63 per participant, about 45% less than the plan’s original $114. The whole process, from RFPs to final negotiations, took about three months. The incumbent investment manager, in contrast, did not keep the business, and the plan achieved a significant fee reduction from the new investment manager.
Two lessons. First, the competition itself (not a change in providers) produced the savings: the incumbent recordkeeper improved its price because it had to. Second, recordkeepers often provide significant discounts when their proprietary investment option is used as the plan’s default investment at conversion (the qualified default investment alternative, or QDIA). Discounts like that need careful review to ensure that the recordkeeper’s proprietary option can stand on its own as a prudent investment, without considering the recordkeeping discount. In this case, the new 3(38) investment manager independently selected the recordkeeper’s QDIA, which created significant value for the plan and its participants.
Common RFP mistakes
- Settling for “close to average.” Average is not the same as reasonable.
- Inviting too few bidders, or only the incumbent and one competitor.
- Letting the incumbent simply match the lowest bid, without testing what the market will actually offer and creating a competitive bidding environment.
- Accepting asset-based pricing without asking for a flat per-participant alternative.
- Looking only at the recordkeeping fee and ignoring revenue from float, rollovers, managed accounts and proprietary funds.
- Deciding the criteria after seeing the bids, which makes the decision harder to defend.
- Not checking the contract against the proposal before signing.
How ClearSage runs RFPs
ClearSage Advisory Group is an independent retirement plan consulting firm that provides fiduciary oversight services to its plan sponsor clients. We don’t manage money or sell investment products, rollovers or wealth services, so we have no stake in which provider wins. Our principals spent years inside a major national recordkeeper, including responsibility for its retirement plan pricing, so we know how recordkeepers build their bids and where they have room to move. From 2023 through 2025 we completed more than 33 search projects covering more than 135 plans, including parallel recordkeeper and investment manager searches.
We can run a single RFP from start to finish, or oversee your plan’s providers on an ongoing basis. Read what a retirement plan consultant does, see our services for employers, or contact us to talk about your plan.
